Skip to content
The Intellectual Framework
Open the Atlas
The Atlas · Polis · Discipline 42 of 58

Ethical Leadership and Social Responsibility

Power, used well.

Read it free10 lessons · about 0.7 hours · 8,791 words
The story

In 1982 seven people in Chicago died after taking Tylenol that someone had laced with cyanide. Johnson and Johnson had done nothing wrong. It recalled thirty-one million bottles anyway, at a cost of a hundred million dollars, and told the public everything. The company survived because it acted as if trust were worth more than the quarter.

The question to carry

Would you do the right thing if no one would ever know?

Say it at the table

Character is what you do when the incentive points the other way.

The film

Watch it in four minutes.

The briefing

What it is, in plain words.

  • 10 lessons
  • 10 modules, each with a test
  • 3 people explained
  • 56 works, places and ideas explained
  • 12 question final exam

Ethical leadership is the practice of guiding others while holding to principle. Social responsibility is the same idea applied to organizations: the recognition that a company or institution answers to more than its owners.

Leaders set the tone by what they do, not what they announce. People watch who is promoted, what is tolerated and how bad news is received, and they behave accordingly. Ethical lapses in organizations are rarely the work of villains. They come from pressure, from small compromises that grow, and from cultures where nobody feels able to object. The safeguards are equally ordinary: clear values, honest incentives, protection for those who raise concerns, and leaders who admit their own mistakes first.

Five ideas to hold

1Integrity

Consistency between what a person says they value and what they actually do.

Integrity comes from the Latin for wholeness. A person or organization has it when words, values and actions line up, including when nobody is watching and when it costs something. It is tested less by dramatic choices than by small ones: reporting an error that favors you, or keeping a promise that has become inconvenient. Research on trust finds that people judge leaders on integrity before competence. A capable leader who cannot be trusted is seen as dangerous.

2Accountability

Being answerable for decisions and their results.

Accountability means that someone can be asked to explain a decision and must bear its consequences. It requires three things: a clear owner for each decision, information about what happened, and a body able to reward or sanction. Where any one is missing, blame diffuses and nothing is learned. Good accountability looks forward as well as back. Its aim is fixing the system so that the failure is not repeated, not only finding someone to punish.

3Stakeholder

Anyone affected by an organization's actions, including staff, customers and the community.

A stakeholder is anyone with something to gain or lose from what an organization does: employees, customers, suppliers, neighbors, lenders and shareholders. R. Edward Freeman argued in 1984 that managers should weigh all of them. The opposing view, associated with Milton Friedman, holds that managers work for the owners and should maximize profit within the law. In practice the two converge more often than the debate suggests, because firms that mistreat stakeholders rarely prosper for long.

4Transparency

Openness about decisions and how they were made.

Transparency is openness about what was decided, by whom and on what grounds. Published accounts, open meetings and freedom of information laws are its tools. The American judge Louis Brandeis put the case in a phrase: sunlight is the best disinfectant. It has limits. Personal privacy and trade secrets are legitimate, and a flood of undigested data can hide as much as it reveals. Useful transparency is information people can actually understand and act on.

5Whistleblowing

Reporting wrongdoing within an organization to those able to act on it.

A whistleblower reports wrongdoing from inside, to managers, regulators or the press. They have exposed fraud, safety failures and abuse that no outside audit found. They often pay heavily, through dismissal, blacklisting or lawsuits. Many countries now have laws protecting them, and some pay rewards. An organization that wants to hear bad news early builds safe internal channels. One that punishes the messenger ensures that it will learn of its problems last.

Five moments that made the field

  1. 1953Howard Bowen publishes Social Responsibilities of the Businessman.
  2. 1970Milton Friedman argues that the duty of business is to increase its profits.
  3. 1977Robert Greenleaf publishes Servant Leadership.
  4. 1984Edward Freeman sets out stakeholder theory.
  5. 2001Enron collapses in an accounting scandal.

Still argued about

Open question 1

Does a company answer to its shareholders or to everyone it affects?

Open question 2

Are leaders born or made?

Open question 3

Can a company do good and maximize profit together?

Plates

Things to look at.

Robben Island
Robben Island Island in Table Bay, South Africa · Wikipedia
Nobel Peace Prize
Nobel Peace Prize One of five Nobel Prizes · Wikipedia
Union Buildings
Union Buildings Seat of the South African Government · Wikipedia
Ideas

Three facts, one myth, one dare.

Did you know · 1The 1982 Tylenol recall is still taught as the model of crisis leadership.
Did you know · 2Mandela invited one of his former jailers to his inauguration.
Did you know · 3People speak up most on teams whose leaders admit their own mistakes.
The myth

Nice leaders finish last.

Tap to turn it over
What is true

Trust lowers the cost of everything an organisation does.

Try this

Admit one mistake to your team this week before anyone points it out.

Start with whySimon Sinek, TEDx · one of the films in this discipline
Inside

10 sections, 10 lessons.

  1. 1

    The briefing

    Integrity · Accountability · Stakeholder · Transparency

  2. 2

    Foundations of Ethical Leadership

    Defining Ethical Leadership · Theories of Ethical Leadership · The Importance of Ethics in Leadership

  3. 3

    Ethical Decision-Making and Integrity

    Frameworks for Ethical Decision-Making · Maintaining Integrity in Leadership · Transparency and Accountability

  4. 4

    Social Responsibility in Organizations

    Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) · Implementing CSR Initiatives · Measuring Social Impact

  5. 5

    Ethical Leadership Across Fields

    Ethical Leadership in Business · Ethics in Public Service and Nonprofits · Ethical Considerations in Science and Technology

  6. 6

    Global Ethics and Cultural Sensitivity

    Understanding Cross-Cultural Ethics · Cultural Relativism vs. Universal Principles · Global Governance and Ethics

  7. 7

    Challenges in Ethical Leadership

    Confronting Corruption and Unethical Behavior · Ethical Leadership in Times of Crisis · The Role of Whistleblowing

  8. 8

    Developing Ethical Leaders

    Fostering Ethical Cultures in Organizations · Education and Training in Ethical Leadership · Role Models and Mentoring

  9. 9

    Social Entrepreneurship and Innovation

    The Rise of Social Entrepreneurship · Case Studies of Social Enterprises · Supporting Social Innovation

  10. 10

    Conclusion

    The Future of Ethical Leadership and Social Responsibility · Personal Reflection and Action

From the text

Leaders set the tone by what they do, not what they announce. People watch who is promoted, what is tolerated and how bad news is received, and they behave accordingly. Ethical lapses in organizations are rarely the work of villains. They come from pressure, from small compromises that grow, and from cultures where nobody feels able to object. The safeguards are equally ordinary: clear values, honest incentives, protection for those who raise concerns, and leaders who admit their own mistakes first.

Keep reading in the Atlas

Figures

People to know.

Nelson Mandela1918-2013

Chose reconciliation over revenge

Mahatma Gandhi1869-1948

Power without violence

Marcus Aurelius121-180

An emperor who doubted himself daily

Wangari Maathai1940-2011

Leadership from the ground up

Peter Drucker1909-2005

Management as a moral practice

Canon

Books to read.

  • MeditationsMarcus Aurelius
  • Long Walk to FreedomNelson Mandela
  • LeadershipJames MacGregor Burns
From the viva

A question from its final exam.

Servant leadership puts first

Who is in it

3 people, each one explained.

Twelve of them are below. In the Atlas every name, work and place in the text opens a short account of who or what it is.

  • Immanuel Kant 1724 to 1804
    German philosopher
  • Muhammad Yunus born 1940
    Bangladeshi banker, Nobel Peace Prize recipient and the former Chief Adviser of Bangladesh
  • Robert K. Greenleaf 1904 to 1990
    American consultant

Descriptions and dates from Wikidata. Portraits from Wikimedia Commons, each linked to its author and license.

Also worth knowing

What a full picture of the field includes.

Every chapter was checked against a list of the names and terms a student of the subject should meet. These are the most important ones the book itself does not name.

B Corporation

A certification for companies that meet standards of social and environmental performance, accountability and transparency.

Fiduciary duty

The legal duty to act in another person's interest, as a trustee must for a beneficiary or a director for a company.

Ronald Heifetzborn 1951

Scholar of adaptive leadership, which separates technical problems from those that require people to change.

Jim Collins1923 to 1996

Author of Good to Great, who described Level 5 leaders: personally humble and fiercely determined.

Psychological safety

Amy Edmondson's term for a team climate in which people can speak up or admit mistakes without fear.

Giving Voice to Values

Mary Gentile's approach to ethics teaching, which rehearses how to act on what you already believe is right.

Dieselgate

The scandal revealed in 2015, when Volkswagen was found to have fitted software to cheat emissions tests.

Enron scandal

The 2001 collapse of an American energy company that had hidden its debts. It led to tougher accounting law.

Shared value

Michael Porter and Mark Kramer's idea that companies can profit by solving social problems.

Bounded ethicalityborn 1955

Max Bazerman's term for the ways good people act unethically without noticing.

Greenwashing

Making a company or product seem greener than it is.

James MacGregor Burns1918 to 2014

Scholar who separated transactional leadership, an exchange of favors, from transforming leadership, which raises both leader and followers.

More of the field

31 more people and ideas a student of this subject should meet. In the Atlas each one opens a card with facts, dates and a portrait.

Abraham MaslowAnita RoddickBlake EdwardsCharles PonziDan ArielyDaniel GolemanIndra NooyiJacinda ArdernJanis IanMalala YousafzaiMax WeberMaxwell (musician)Mother TeresaNiccolò MachiavelliPhilip ZimbardoPlatoStanley MilgramStephen CoveySun TzuTheodore SchultzBoeingFacebookNestléSustainable Development GoalsTheory XTheranosUnileverUnion CarbideVolkswagenWells FargoWorldCom

Read Ethical Leadership and Social Responsibility.

Free. The film, the briefing and the first section open without an account.