Skip to content
The Intellectual Framework
Open the Atlas
The Atlas · Memoria · Discipline 55 of 58

Comparative Religion and Spirituality

The great traditions, side by side.

Read it free10 lessons · about 0.7 hours · 9,477 words
The story

In 1893 a young monk from Calcutta stood up at the World's Parliament of Religions in Chicago. He had arrived without credentials and almost without money. He began, "Sisters and brothers of America," and seven thousand people rose and applauded for two minutes. Swami Vivekananda had said one sentence. The idea that faiths could speak to each other as equals had found its moment.

The question to carry

Do the world's religions ask the same question and answer differently, or ask different questions?

Say it at the table

Compare religions to understand people, not to keep score.

The film

Watch it in four minutes.

The briefing

What it is, in plain words.

  • 10 lessons
  • 10 modules, each with a test
  • 8 people explained
  • 137 works, places and ideas explained
  • 12 question final exam

Comparative religion sets the world's traditions side by side to see what they share and where they differ. Its aim is understanding, not a ranking. Spirituality refers to the personal search for meaning and connection, inside or outside organized religion.

The comparison shows both likeness and real difference. Nearly all traditions teach compassion, restraint and care for the stranger. They differ on the basics. Is there one god, many or none? Is the human problem sin, ignorance or disharmony? Does life happen once or recur? The Abrahamic faiths stress a covenant with one God. The Indian traditions stress release from the cycle of rebirth. Chinese thought stresses harmony in this life. Knowing these outlines makes dialogue possible and caricature harder.

Five ideas to hold

1Dharma

In Indian traditions, the right way of living and the order that sustains the world.

Dharma has no single English equivalent. In Hinduism it means the moral order of the universe and each person's duty within it, which varies with stage of life and role. In Buddhism it means the Buddha's teaching and the truth that the teaching points to. In both it carries the sense of what holds things together. Living by dharma is living in accord with how things really are, and that is why it is rewarding.

2Covenant

A binding agreement between God and a people, central to Judaism, Christianity and Islam.

A covenant is a solemn agreement that creates a relationship with obligations on both sides. In the Hebrew Bible, God makes covenants with Noah, with Abraham and with the people of Israel at Sinai, promising faithfulness and asking obedience to the law. Christians speak of a new covenant through Jesus. Muslims speak of a primordial covenant between God and all humanity. The idea frames religion as a relationship, more than as a philosophy.

3Nirvana

In Buddhism, release from suffering and the cycle of rebirth.

Nirvana literally means blowing out, as of a flame. What goes out is craving, hatred and delusion, which the Buddha identified as the causes of suffering. With them ends the cycle of rebirth. It is not a heaven and not simply nothing. Buddhist texts mostly describe it by what it is free of. The Buddha is said to have reached it in life and continued teaching for forty-five years, so it is a state that can be lived.

4Mysticism

The pursuit of direct personal experience of the divine or ultimate reality.

Mystics seek direct experience of the divine or of ultimate reality, beyond doctrine and ritual. Every major religion has such a current: Sufism in Islam, Kabbalah in Judaism, contemplative prayer in Christianity, Zen in Buddhism, Advaita in Hinduism. Accounts from very different traditions sound alike. They speak of unity, of the loss of the ordinary self, and of something that cannot be put into words. Religious authorities have often regarded mystics with a mixture of reverence and suspicion.

5Interfaith dialogue

Conversation between people of different religions aimed at mutual understanding.

Interfaith dialogue brings people of different religions together to understand one another. It is not an attempt to convert or to merge. It ranges from formal meetings of leaders to neighbors cooperating on a food bank. The modern movement is usually dated to the 1893 Parliament of the World's Religions in Chicago. Its working rules are simple: let each tradition describe itself, compare your best with their best, and do not pretend that real differences are absent.

Five moments that made the field

  1. 1870Max Muller lectures on a science of religion.
  2. 1893The first Parliament of the World's Religions meets in Chicago.
  3. 1902William James publishes The Varieties of Religious Experience.
  4. 1917Rudolf Otto publishes The Idea of the Holy.
  5. 1965The Second Vatican Council declares respect for other faiths.

Still argued about

Open question 1

Do all religions point to one truth, or do they really differ?

Open question 2

Can a person be spiritual without religion?

Open question 3

Can a scholar set aside their own beliefs when studying someone else's?

Plates

Things to look at.

Golden Temple
Golden Temple Sikh religious site in Punjab, India · Wikipedia
Borobudur
Borobudur 9th-century Buddhist temple in Java, Indonesia · Wikipedia
Dome of the Rock
Dome of the Rock Islamic building in Al-Aqsa, Jerusalem · Wikipedia
Ideas

Three facts, one myth, one dare.

Did you know · 1A version of the Golden Rule appears in the scriptures of every major world religion.
Did you know · 2The Sikh scripture is treated as a living teacher.
Did you know · 3Jerusalem is sacred to three faiths.
The myth

All religions are basically the same.

Tap to turn it over
What is true

They share much of their ethics, but differ deeply on what is wrong with the world and what would fix it.

Try this

Read one page of a scripture that is not your own.

The five major world religionsTED-Ed · one of the films in this discipline
Inside

10 sections, 10 lessons.

  1. 1

    The briefing

    Dharma · Covenant · Nirvana · Mysticism

  2. 2

    Introduction to Comparative Religion

    Defining Religion and Spirituality · The Purpose of Comparative Religion · Historical Overview

  3. 3

    Indigenous Religions and Spiritualities

    African Traditional Religions · Native American Spirituality · Australian Aboriginal Spirituality · Shamanism

  4. 4

    Dharmic Religions

    Hinduism · Buddhism · Jainism · Sikhism

  5. 5

    Abrahamic Religions

    Judaism · Christianity · Islam · Baha'i Faith

  6. 6

    East Asian Religions and Philosophies

    Confucianism · Taoism · Shinto

  7. 7

    New Religious Movements and Alternative Spiritualities

    Definition and Characteristics · Examples and Overview · The Role of Technology and Globalization

  8. 8

    Comparative Themes in Religion and Spirituality

    Concepts of the Divine · Rituals and Worship · Ethics and Morality · Afterlife and Salvation

  9. 9

    Interfaith Dialogue and Ecumenism

    Principles and Goals · Historical and Contemporary Examples · The Role of Interfaith Dialogue in Addressing Global Issues

  10. 10

    Conclusion

    The Importance of Religious and Spiritual Diversity · Future Trends in Religion and Spirituality

From the text

The comparison shows both likeness and real difference. Nearly all traditions teach compassion, restraint and care for the stranger. They differ on the basics. Is there one god, many or none? Is the human problem sin, ignorance or disharmony? Does life happen once or recur? The Abrahamic faiths stress a covenant with one God. The Indian traditions stress release from the cycle of rebirth. Chinese thought stresses harmony in this life. Knowing these outlines makes dialogue possible and caricature harder.

Keep reading in the Atlas

Figures

People to know.

Swami Vivekananda1863-1902

Introduced Vedanta to the West

Rumi1207-1273

Sufi poet of divine love

Siddhartha Gautamac. 5th century BC

The Buddha

Laozic. 6th century BC

Traditional author of the Tao Te Ching

Karen Armstrongborn 1944

Historian of religion

Canon

Books to read.

  • The World's ReligionsHuston Smith
  • A History of GodKaren Armstrong
  • Tao Te ChingLaozi
  • The Bhagavad Gitatrans. Eknath Easwaran
From the viva

A question from its final exam.

The Four Noble Truths belong to

Who is in it

8 people, each one explained.

Twelve of them are below. In the Atlas every name, work and place in the text opens a short account of who or what it is.

  • Muhammad 571 to 632
    Arabian political leader and the founder of Islam
  • Guru Nanak 1469 to 1539
    First Sikh Guru and founder of Sikhism
  • Baha'u'llah 1817 to 1892
    Founder of the Bahá'í Faith
  • Confucius c. 551 BC to c. 479 BC
    5th-century BCE Chinese philosopher and politician
  • Laozi c. 580 BC to c. 501 BC
    6th-century BC semi-legendary Chinese philosopher, founder of Taoism
  • Jesus Christ c. 6 BC to 30
    Central figure of Christianity (c. 6 or 4 BC – AD 30 or 33)
  • L. Ron Hubbard 1911 to 1986
    American writer and Scientology founder
  • Siddhartha Gautama c. 501 BC to c. 501 BC
    Indian philosopher and the founder of Buddhism

Descriptions and dates from Wikidata. Portraits from Wikimedia Commons, each linked to its author and license.

Also worth knowing

What a full picture of the field includes.

Every chapter was checked against a list of the names and terms a student of the subject should meet. These are the most important ones the book itself does not name.

Zoroastrianism

The ancient Iranian religion of the prophet Zoroaster, built on the struggle between truth and the lie.

Axial Age

Karl Jaspers's term for the centuries around 500 BC in which the great traditions of China, India, Israel and Greece took shape.

Hans Küng1928 to 2021

Swiss theologian who argued that there can be no peace among nations without peace among religions.

Ninian Smart1927 to 2001

Scholar who described religions by seven dimensions, including ritual, myth, doctrine, ethics and experience.

Diana Eckborn 1945

Founder of the Pluralism Project at Harvard, which studies religious diversity in America.

Nostra aetate

The 1965 declaration in which the Catholic Church said it rejects nothing that is true and holy in other religions.

Thích Nhất Hạnh1926 to 2022

Vietnamese Zen monk who taught mindfulness and "engaged Buddhism" to the West.

Thomas Merton1915 to 1968

American Trappist monk who opened a dialogue with Buddhist and other contemplatives.

John Hick1922 to 2012

Philosopher who proposed that the great religions are different human responses to one ultimate reality.

Perennial philosophy

The view that the world's religions share a single core of mystical truth. Critics reply that the differences are real.

Abraham Joshua Heschel1907 to 1972

Rabbi and theologian who marched with Martin Luther King and worked for understanding between Jews and Christians.

Ramakrishna1836 to 1886

Bengali mystic who practiced several religions and taught that they are paths to the same goal.

More of the field

14 more people and ideas a student of this subject should meet. In the Atlas each one opens a card with facts, dates and a portrait.

Friedrich SchleiermacherFrithjof SchuonKarl RahnerMartin BuberMircea EliadeNathan SöderblomPaul TillichPierre Teilhard de ChardinRaimon PanikkarWilfred ThesigerÉmile DurkheimDalai LamaSermon on the MountTrinity

Read Comparative Religion and Spirituality.

Free. The film, the briefing and the first section open without an account.