Skip to content
The Intellectual Framework
Open the Atlas
The Atlas · Logos · Discipline 18 of 58

Philosophy of Science and Technology

What makes science science, and what we may do with it.

Read it free19 lessons · about 1.1 hours · 15,449 words
The story

For two centuries Newton's physics passed every test anyone could invent. Then it failed one, at the orbit of Mercury, by a hair. Karl Popper drew the lesson: no amount of evidence proves a theory, but one clean failure can sink it. A good idea is one that sticks its neck out.

The question to carry

Should we build something just because we can?

Say it at the table

Science is not a body of facts. It is a method for being wrong in public.

The film

Watch it in four minutes.

The briefing

What it is, in plain words.

  • 19 lessons
  • 18 modules, each with a test
  • 15 people explained
  • 62 works, places and ideas explained
  • 12 question final exam

The philosophy of science asks what science is, how it earns its authority, and where that authority ends. The philosophy of technology asks what our tools do to us and who should decide how they are used.

Science does not prove theories. It tests them, discards the ones that fail, and holds the survivors provisionally. Popper made the willingness to be refuted the mark of a scientific claim. Kuhn showed that fields also lurch through revolutions, when an old framework gives way to a new one. Technology raises a separate question. A tool is never only a means. It rearranges what is easy, what is expected and who has power, usually faster than anyone chooses.

Five ideas to hold

1Falsifiability

A claim is scientific only if some possible observation could show it to be wrong.

Karl Popper asked what separates science from things that only look like it. His answer was risk. Einstein's theory predicted that starlight would bend by a specific amount near the Sun. Had the 1919 eclipse measurements come out differently, the theory would have been refuted. A horoscope vague enough to fit anyone risks nothing. For Popper a theory that cannot be wrong is not strong. It is empty. Scientists may never prove a theory, but they can test it hard.

2Paradigm

The shared framework of theory and method within which a field does its normal work.

Thomas Kuhn argued in 1962 that science does not advance by steady accumulation. Most of the time, researchers work inside a shared framework, a paradigm, solving the puzzles it sets. Anomalies pile up until the framework cracks and a new one replaces it, as when Copernicus displaced an Earth-centered cosmos. Kuhn called this a paradigm shift. After one, scientists do not just know more. They see the same data differently and ask different questions.

3Induction

Reasoning from observed cases to a general rule. It can make a claim probable but never certain.

Every swan you have seen is white, so you conclude that all swans are white. Then you visit Australia and meet a black one. Induction, reasoning from cases to a general rule, is how we learn about the world, and it never guarantees its conclusions. David Hume pointed out that we cannot even justify trusting it without using it. Science lives with the problem by treating all general laws as open to revision.

4Peer review

Scrutiny of research by other experts before publication. It filters errors but does not guarantee truth.

Before a study is published in a scientific journal, the editor sends it to other researchers in the field, who look for errors and gaps. The system catches many mistakes. It is not a guarantee. Reviewers are unpaid and busy, they rarely see the raw data, and fraud can slip through. A peer-reviewed paper is best read as having passed a first check. Confidence should come from findings that other teams have repeated.

5Precautionary principle

Where an action risks serious harm, lack of full certainty is not a reason to go ahead unchecked.

When an action might cause serious or irreversible harm, the precautionary principle says not to wait for proof before acting carefully. It was written into the 1992 Rio Declaration on the environment. Supporters point to leaded petrol and asbestos, where delay cost lives. Critics say that applied strictly it would block any new technology, since nothing can be proved perfectly safe, and that doing nothing carries risks too. In practice it shifts the burden of proof.

Five moments that made the field

  1. 1620Francis Bacon publishes the Novum Organum and calls for knowledge built on observation.
  2. 1739David Hume raises the problem of induction.
  3. 1934Karl Popper makes falsifiability the test of a scientific claim.
  4. 1954Heidegger publishes The Question Concerning Technology.
  5. 1962Thomas Kuhn publishes The Structure of Scientific Revolutions.

Still argued about

Open question 1

Do scientific theories describe reality or only predict what we will observe?

Open question 2

Is technology neutral, or does it carry values of its own?

Open question 3

Who should decide which technologies get built?

Plates

Things to look at.

Large Hadron Collider
Large Hadron Collider Particle accelerator at CERN, Switzerland · Wikipedia
Trinity (nuclear test)
Trinity (nuclear test) First detonation of a nuclear weapon · Wikipedia
Royal Society
Royal Society British learned society · Wikipedia
Ideas

Three facts, one myth, one dare.

Did you know · 1The word scientist was only coined in 1833.
Did you know · 2Newton wrote more about alchemy and theology than about physics.
Did you know · 3Continental drift was mocked for decades before plate tectonics confirmed it.
The myth

Science proves things.

Tap to turn it over
What is true

Science never proves. It fails to disprove, again and again, until confidence is earned.

Try this

Take a claim you believe and look for the strongest evidence against it.

Feynman on Scientific MethodRichard Feynman lecture · one of the films in this discipline
Inside

18 sections, 19 lessons.

  1. 1

    The briefing

    Falsifiability · Paradigm · Induction · Peer review

  2. 2

    Introduction to Philosophy of Science and Technology

    Definition and Scope · Historical Development · Importance and Applications · Nature of Knowledge

  3. 3

    Philosophy of Scientific Method

    Inductivism · Falsificationism · Bayesianism · Realism vs. Antirealism

  4. 4

    Metaphysics and Philosophy of Nature

    Ontology: The Nature of Reality · Philosophy of Space and Time · Causality and Determinism vs. Indeterminism

  5. 5

    Philosophy of Technology

    Definition and Scope · Technological Determinism · Ethics of Technology · Technology and Human Enhancement

  6. 6

    Philosophy of Biology

    Teleology in Biology · Reductionism vs. Holism · Evolutionary Epistemology

  7. 7

    Philosophy of Physics

    Interpretations of Quantum Mechanics · Theories of Time · Symmetry and Conservation Laws

  8. 8

    Philosophy of Mind and Artificial Intelligence

    The Mind-Body Problem · Consciousness and Artificial Intelligence · Ethics of AI and Machine Learning

  9. 9

    Philosophy of Mathematics

    Platonism vs. Nominalism · The Foundations of Mathematics · Mathematical Realism vs. Anti-Realism

  10. 10

    Ethics of Science and Technology

    Responsible Conduct of Research · Dual Use Dilemmas · Science, Technology, and Social Justice

  11. 11

    Philosophy of Information and Communication

    Information Theory · Ethics of Information Technology · Digital Privacy and Surveillance

  12. 12

    Philosophy of Medicine and Biotechnology

    Medical Ethics · Biomedical Enhancement · Bioethics and Emerging Technologies

  13. 13

    Philosophy of Environment and Sustainability

    Environmental Ethics · Deep Ecology · Sustainability and Intergenerational Justice

  14. 14

    Philosophy of Space Exploration and Astrobiology

    Astrobiology and the Search for Extraterrestrial Life · Ethics of Space Exploration · The Future of Human Colonization in Space

  15. 15

    Philosophy of Neuroscience

    Free Will and Neurodeterminism · Moral Responsibility and Brain States · Neuroethics and Neuroenhancement

  16. 16

    Philosophy of Engineering and Design

    Design Ethics · Values in Engineering · Sustainable Design Principles

  17. 17

    Philosophy of Quantum Computing

    Quantum Computing and Superposition · Implications for Cryptography · Ethical Issues in Quantum Computing

  18. 18

    Philosophy of Social Science

    Ontology and Epistemology in the Social Sciences · Ethics in Social Research · Reflexivity and Objectivity in Social Inquiry

From the text

Science does not prove theories. It tests them, discards the ones that fail, and holds the survivors provisionally. Popper made the willingness to be refuted the mark of a scientific claim. Kuhn showed that fields also lurch through revolutions, when an old framework gives way to a new one. Technology raises a separate question. A tool is never only a means. It rearranges what is easy, what is expected and who has power, usually faster than anyone chooses.

Keep reading in the Atlas

Figures

People to know.

Karl Popper1902-1994

Falsifiability

Thomas Kuhn1922-1996

Paradigm shifts

Francis Bacon1561-1626

Champion of the empirical method

Paul Feyerabend1924-1994

Against a single method

Martin Heidegger1889-1976

Questioned technology's hold on us

Canon

Books to read.

  • The Logic of Scientific DiscoveryKarl Popper
  • The Structure of Scientific RevolutionsThomas Kuhn
  • The Demon-Haunted WorldCarl Sagan
From the viva

A question from its final exam.

Falsifiability is most associated with

Who is in it

15 people, each one explained.

Twelve of them are below. In the Atlas every name, work and place in the text opens a short account of who or what it is.

  • Plato c. 429 BC to c. 349 BC
    4th-century BCE Greek philosopher
  • Aristotle c. 384 BC to c. 322 BC
    Greek philosopher
  • Karl Popper 1902 to 1994
    Austrian–British philosopher, academic and social commentator
  • Arne Naess 1912 to 2009
    Norwegian philosopher and mountain climber
  • Bertrand Russell 1872 to 1970
    British philosopher and logician
  • Claude Shannon 1916 to 2001
    American mathematician and information theorist
  • David Hilbert 1862 to 1943
    German mathematician
  • David Hume 1711 to 1776
    Scottish philosopher, economist, and historian
  • Gottlob Frege 1848 to 1925
    German philosopher, logician, and mathematician
  • John Searle 1932 to 2025
    American philosopher
  • John Stuart Mill 1806 to 1873
    British philosopher and political economist
  • Marx 1818 to 1883
    German-born philosopher

Descriptions and dates from Wikidata. Portraits from Wikimedia Commons, each linked to its author and license.

Also worth knowing

What a full picture of the field includes.

Every chapter was checked against a list of the names and terms a student of the subject should meet. These are the most important ones the book itself does not name.

Imre Lakatos1922 to 1974

Philosopher who described science as competing research programmes, each with a protected core, which succeed or decay over time.

Vienna Circle

The group of the 1920s and 1930s who held that a statement has meaning only if it can be checked by observation or logic.

W. V. O. Quine1908 to 2000

Philosopher who argued that our beliefs face evidence together, as a web, so that no single claim is tested alone.

Bruno Latour1947 to 2022

French thinker who studied laboratories like an anthropologist and described how facts are built by networks of people and instruments.

Jacques Ellul1912 to 1994

French critic who argued that technique, the search for the most efficient means, has become a force that shapes society on its own terms.

Lewis Mumford1895 to 1990

American writer on technology and cities who warned of the "megamachine", society organized like a machine.

Technological determinism

The view that technology drives social change. Its critics answer that societies also choose and shape their tools.

Ian Hacking1936 to 2023

Philosopher who argued that experiment has a life of its own, and that we should believe in entities we can use to do things.

Hans Jonas1903 to 1993

Philosopher who argued that our power over the future creates a new duty: act so that human life can continue.

Underdetermination

The problem that the same evidence can fit more than one theory, so evidence alone does not always decide between them.

More of the field

11 more people and ideas a student of this subject should meet. In the Atlas each one opens a card with facts, dates and a portrait.

Alan TuringCharles Sanders PeirceDonna HarawayGilbert SimondonHenri PoincaréKarl PolanyiMarshall McLuhanNick BostromPhilip KitcherPierre DuhemRudolf Carnap

Read Philosophy of Science and Technology.

Free. The film, the briefing and the first section open without an account.