Skip to content
The Intellectual Framework
Open the Atlas
The Atlas · Logos · Discipline 44 of 58

Philosophy of Art and Culture

What art is for, and who gets to say.

Read it free10 lessons · about 0.7 hours · 9,980 words
The story

In 1917 Marcel Duchamp bought a urinal from a plumbing supplier, signed it "R. Mutt," and submitted it to an exhibition that had promised to show anything. It was rejected. Decades later a poll of art experts named it the most influential artwork of its age. The object was nothing. The question it asked was everything.

The question to carry

If you cannot tell a masterpiece from a forgery, is there a difference?

Say it at the table

Asking "is it art?" is less useful than asking "what is it doing?"

The film

Watch it in four minutes.

The briefing

What it is, in plain words.

  • 10 lessons
  • 10 modules, each with a test
  • 27 people explained
  • 52 works, places and ideas explained
  • 12 question final exam

The philosophy of art asks what art is, what it is for, and how its value should be judged. The philosophy of culture asks the same of the wider web of meanings a society lives inside. These are old questions that modern art has made urgent.

For centuries art was defined as imitation of the world. Later theories stressed the expression of feeling, or the arrangement of form for its own sake. In the twentieth century artists exhibited ordinary objects and forced a harder answer: perhaps something is art because of the setting and the conversation around it. Running beneath is the problem of taste. Either some judgments are better than others, or beauty is only preference. Most people believe both, depending on the day.

Five ideas to hold

1Mimesis

The idea that art imitates or represents reality.

Mimesis is Greek for imitation. Plato distrusted art for this reason. A painting of a bed is a copy of a bed, which is itself a copy of the ideal form, so art stands twice removed from truth. Aristotle answered that imitation is how humans learn, and that tragedy shows what is universal, not just what happened. For two thousand years the question of how truly art represents reality dominated Western thinking about it.

2Expression theory

The view that art's purpose is to convey the feeling of its maker.

The Romantics turned the question around. Art is not a mirror of the world but a lamp from within the artist. Leo Tolstoy argued that art exists to pass feeling from one person to another, and R. G. Collingwood held that an artist discovers an emotion in the act of expressing it. The theory fits music and lyric poetry well. It struggles with works made coldly on commission that move us all the same.

3Formalism

The view that a work's value lies in its form, not its subject or message.

Formalists hold that what matters in art is form: line, color, shape, structure. Clive Bell wrote in 1914 that all true art has "significant form", and that subject matter is beside the point. The view helped audiences accept abstract painting, which depicts nothing. Its weakness is that it sets aside history, politics and meaning, which many viewers feel are part of why a work matters. Most critics now use formal analysis as one tool among several.

4Aesthetic judgment

A claim that something is beautiful or good as art, usually made as if others ought to agree.

When you call a sunset beautiful, you are not just reporting that you like it. Kant observed that you speak as if everyone ought to agree, even though you can point to no rule that proves it. He called this a judgment of taste, and thought it rested on a pleasure free of personal interest. The puzzle endures. Aesthetic judgments feel like more than preference and less than fact, and arguments about them never fully settle.

5Aura

The unique presence of an original work, which copies do not carry.

Walter Benjamin argued in 1936 that an original artwork has an aura: a presence that comes from its unique existence in one place, with its own history. Photography and film can copy an image endlessly, and the aura withers. He saw both loss and gain in this, since copies free art from ritual and bring it to the masses. The idea helps explain why crowds still queue to stand before a Mona Lisa they have seen a thousand times in print.

Five moments that made the field

  1. c. 375 BCPlato argues that art is imitation and cannot be trusted.
  2. 1757Hume publishes Of the Standard of Taste.
  3. 1835Hegel's lectures on aesthetics are published.
  4. 1936Walter Benjamin publishes his essay on art in the age of mechanical reproduction.
  5. 1964Arthur Danto writes The Artworld after seeing Warhol's Brillo boxes.

Still argued about

Open question 1

Can anything be art if the art world says so?

Open question 2

Is high culture really better than popular culture?

Open question 3

Should art be judged by moral standards?

Plates

Things to look at.

Fountain (Duchamp)
Fountain (Duchamp) 1917 sculpture by Elsa von Freytag-Loringhoven · Wikipedia
Campbell's Soup Cans
Campbell's Soup Cans Artwork series by Andy Warhol (1961–62) · Wikipedia
Black Square
Black Square 1915 painting by Kazimir Malevich · Wikipedia
Ideas

Three facts, one myth, one dare.

Did you know · 1A blank canvas, a silent piece of music and a signed urinal have all been shown as art.
Did you know · 2A forged Vermeer fooled leading experts and a Nazi leader.
Did you know · 3Kant argued that when we call something beautiful we expect others to agree.
The myth

Beauty is entirely in the eye of the beholder.

Tap to turn it over
What is true

Tastes differ, yet people across cultures agree far more than chance would predict.

Try this

Decide whether a perfect copy of a painting is worth less than the original, and why.

Inside

10 sections, 10 lessons.

  1. 1

    The briefing

    Mimesis · Expression theory · Formalism · Aesthetic judgment

  2. 2

    Foundations of Aesthetics

    Defining Aesthetics · Historical Overview · Key Concepts in Aesthetics · Conclusion

  3. 3

    Art and the Human Condition

    Art as a Mirror of Society · Art and Identity · The Cathartic and Transformative Power of Art · Conclusion

  4. 4

    Major Philosophical Theories of Art

    Imitation and Representation: Plato, Aristotle, and the Mimesis Theory · Expressionism: Art as Expression of Emotion and Inner States · Formalism and Structuralism: Focus on Form, Structure, and Intrinsic Qualities · Post-Structuralism and Deconstruction: Questioning the Stability of Meaning in Art

  5. 5

    The Role of the Artist

    The Artist as Creator: Concepts of Genius, Creativity, and Inspiration · The Artist in Society: Responsibilities, Influence, and the Relationship with the Audience · Conclusion

  6. 6

    Art, Culture, and Technology

    The Impact of Technology on Art · Digital Art and New Media · Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction · Conclusion

  7. 7

    Understanding Culture Philosophically

    Culture as a System of Meaning · Cultural Relativism and Universalism · The Culture Industry · Conclusion

  8. 8

    Art, Ethics, and Society

    The Ethical Responsibilities of Art · Censorship and Freedom of Expression · Art as a Vehicle for Social Critique · Conclusion

  9. 9

    Intersections of Art, Culture, and Politics

    Art as Political Activism · Cultural Imperialism and Globalization · Identity Politics and Representation in Art · Conclusion

  10. 10

    Conclusion

    The Continuing Evolution of Art and Culture · Personal Engagement with Art and Culture

From the text

For centuries art was defined as imitation of the world. Later theories stressed the expression of feeling, or the arrangement of form for its own sake. In the twentieth century artists exhibited ordinary objects and forced a harder answer: perhaps something is art because of the setting and the conversation around it. Running beneath is the problem of taste. Either some judgments are better than others, or beauty is only preference. Most people believe both, depending on the day.

Keep reading in the Atlas

Figures

People to know.

Marcel Duchamp1887-1968

The readymade

Walter Benjamin1892-1940

Art in the age of mechanical reproduction

Arthur Danto1924-2013

The artworld

Leo Tolstoy1828-1910

What Is Art?

Susan Sontag1933-2004

Against Interpretation

Canon

Books to read.

  • What Is Art?Leo Tolstoy
  • The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical ReproductionWalter Benjamin
  • Against InterpretationSusan Sontag
From the viva

A question from its final exam.

Duchamp's Fountain is an example of a

Who is in it

27 people, each one explained.

Twelve of them are below. In the Atlas every name, work and place in the text opens a short account of who or what it is.

  • Plato c. 429 BC to c. 349 BC
    4th-century BCE Greek philosopher
  • Aristotle c. 384 BC to c. 322 BC
    Greek philosopher
  • Roland Barthes 1915 to 1980
    French philosopher and essayist
  • Immanuel Kant 1724 to 1804
    German philosopher
  • Jacques Derrida 1930 to 2004
    French philosopher
  • Max Horkheimer 1895 to 1973
    German philosopher and sociologist
  • Walter Benjamin 1892 to 1940
    German cultural critic, philosopher and social critic
  • Antonio Gramsci 1891 to 1937
    Italian Marxist philosopher, writer, and politician
  • Clifford Geertz 1926 to 2006
    American anthropologist
  • David Hume 1711 to 1776
    Scottish philosopher, economist, and historian
  • Edmund Burke 1729 to 1797
    Anglo-Irish statesman, political theorist and conservative philosopher
  • Edvard Munch 1863 to 1944
    Norwegian painter

Descriptions and dates from Wikidata. Portraits from Wikimedia Commons, each linked to its author and license.

Also worth knowing

What a full picture of the field includes.

Every chapter was checked against a list of the names and terms a student of the subject should meet. These are the most important ones the book itself does not name.

Arthur Schopenhauer1788 to 1860

Philosopher who held that art, and music above all, gives brief release from the restless striving of the will.

John Dewey1859 to 1952

American philosopher whose Art as Experience (1934) placed art in the heightened experiences of ordinary life.

Clement Greenberg1909 to 1994

American critic who championed abstract painting and argued that each art should attend to what is unique to its medium.

Institutional theory of art

George Dickie's view that something is art when the art world treats it as a candidate for appreciation.

Intentional fallacy

The claim by Wimsatt and Beardsley that an author's intentions are not the standard for judging a work.

Susan Sontag1933 to 2004

Critic whose essay Against Interpretation (1964) asked for attention to the surface and form of art, not to hidden meanings.

Culture industry

Adorno and Horkheimer's term for mass entertainment produced like factory goods, which they said dulls critical thought.

Male gaze

Laura Mulvey's 1975 term for the way film has framed women as objects to be looked at by men.

Rasa

The Indian theory, from the Natyashastra, that art distills emotions into flavors the audience can savor.

Wabi-sabi

The Japanese sense of beauty in what is simple, imperfect and passing.

Nelson Goodman1906 to 1998

Philosopher who treated the arts as symbol systems and asked "when is art?" in place of "what is art?"

Jean Baudrillard1929 to 2007

French theorist who argued that copies and images now stand in for reality, a condition he called hyperreality.

More of the field

32 more people and ideas a student of this subject should meet. In the Atlas each one opens a card with facts, dates and a portrait.

Albert CamusAndré MalrauxArnold BöcklinBharata (Jainism)Charles BaudelaireErnst GombrichErwin PanofskyF. R. LeavisFriedrich NietzscheGilles DeleuzeGuy DebordGyörgy LukácsHans-Georg GadamerHeinrich WölfflinJacques RancièreJean-Paul SartreJohann Joachim WinckelmannJohn RuskinJudith ButlerJulia KristevaKwame Anthony AppiahLinda NochlinMarshall McLuhanMartin HeideggerMaurice Merleau-PontyMichel FoucaultMorris (cartoonist)Pierre BourdieuPlotinusRoger ScrutonXie He (artist)Zeki Velidi Togan

Read Philosophy of Art and Culture.

Free. The film, the briefing and the first section open without an account.