Skip to content
The Intellectual Framework
Open the Atlas
The Atlas · Logos · Discipline 01 of 58

Philosophy and Critical Thinking

The love of wisdom, and the discipline of not fooling yourself.

Read it free13 lessons · about 0.9 hours · 12,673 words
The story

In 399 BC an Athenian jury sentenced a seventy-year-old man to death for asking questions. Socrates could have fled. He stayed, drank the hemlock, and left behind the one habit every thinker since has had to learn: examine what you believe before you defend it.

The question to carry

If you could not be wrong about something, how would you know?

Say it at the table

Most arguments are not about facts. They are about definitions nobody stopped to agree on.

The film

Watch it in four minutes.

The briefing

What it is, in plain words.

  • 13 lessons
  • 13 modules, each with a test
  • 63 people explained
  • 123 works, places and ideas explained
  • 12 question final exam

Philosophy asks the questions that come before every other subject: what exists, what we can know, how we should live, and what makes an argument good. It has no laboratory. Its method is the argument itself, stated clearly enough that someone else can find the flaw.

The Western tradition runs from the Greeks through medieval theology to the modern split between rationalists, who trusted reason, and empiricists, who trusted the senses. Kant tried to join them. Parallel traditions in India and China asked the same questions with different starting points. The practical payoff is critical thinking: separating a claim from the reasons offered for it, and noticing when the reasons do not reach.

Five ideas to hold

1Premise and conclusion

An argument is a set of premises offered in support of a conclusion. To judge it, check whether the premises are true and whether the conclusion follows.

Every argument has the same skeleton: reasons, then a claim they are meant to support. Finding the skeleton is the first job. "All humans are mortal. Socrates is human. So Socrates is mortal" has two premises and one conclusion. In real speech the conclusion often comes first and some premises are left unsaid. Writing the argument out in numbered lines shows what is actually being claimed, and which unstated assumption is carrying the weight.

2Validity and soundness

A valid argument has a conclusion that must follow from its premises. A sound argument is valid and its premises are also true.

Validity is about shape, not truth. "All cats are reptiles. Tom is a cat. So Tom is a reptile" is valid, because if the premises were true the conclusion would have to be. It is not sound, because the first premise is false. This gives you two separate ways to challenge any argument. Either a premise is false, or the conclusion does not follow from the premises. Naming which one keeps a disagreement from going in circles.

3A priori and a posteriori

Some things are known by reasoning alone, like arithmetic. Others are known only by experience, like the boiling point of water.

You can know that seven plus five is twelve without leaving your chair. You cannot know whether it is raining without looking. The first kind of knowledge is a priori, prior to experience. The second is a posteriori, after experience. Rationalists such as Descartes thought the deepest truths were of the first kind. Empiricists such as Hume thought all real knowledge of the world was of the second. Kant's project was to show how the two work together.

4The Socratic method

Teaching by asking questions until a hidden assumption comes to the surface. It tests beliefs instead of delivering them.

Socrates claimed to know nothing and taught by asking. He would ask someone to define courage or justice, then test the definition against cases until it broke. The aim was not to humiliate. It was to show that a confident belief rested on something unexamined. The method survives in law schools, in good therapy and in any teacher who answers a question with a better question. Its rule is simple: never accept a definition until you have tried to find a counterexample.

5Occam's razor

When two explanations fit the facts equally well, prefer the one that assumes less.

William of Ockham, a fourteenth-century friar, advised against multiplying entities beyond necessity. If your keys are missing, the explanation that you left them in your coat needs fewer assumptions than the explanation that a burglar took only your keys. The razor does not say the simpler account is always true. It says simpler accounts should be tried first, because each added assumption is another place to be wrong. Scientists use it to choose between theories that fit the same evidence.

Five moments that made the field

  1. 399 BCSocrates is tried and put to death in Athens for questioning too much.
  2. c. 375 BCPlato writes the Republic and asks what justice is.
  3. 1641Descartes publishes the Meditations and doubts everything he can.
  4. 1781Kant publishes the Critique of Pure Reason and sets limits on what reason can know.
  5. 1921Wittgenstein publishes the Tractatus and turns philosophy toward language.

Still argued about

Open question 1

Do we have free will if every event has a cause?

Open question 2

Is anything right or wrong apart from what a culture happens to believe?

Open question 3

Can we be certain of anything beyond our own experience?

Plates

Things to look at.

The School of Athens
The School of Athens Fresco by Raphael · Wikipedia
Stoa of Attalos
Stoa of Attalos Ancient covered walkway in Athens, Greece · Wikipedia
The Death of Socrates
The Death of Socrates 1787 painting by Jacques-Louis David · Wikipedia
Ideas

Three facts, one myth, one dare.

Did you know · 1The word philosophy is Greek for love of wisdom.
Did you know · 2Aristotle was the tutor of Alexander the Great.
Did you know · 3The word academy comes from the grove outside Athens where Plato taught.
The myth

Philosophy never settles anything.

Tap to turn it over
What is true

Physics, psychology and economics all began as philosophy. They left home once their questions became testable.

Try this

Pick a belief you hold strongly and write the best argument against it.

What is Philosophy?Crash Course · one of the films in this discipline
Inside

13 sections, 13 lessons.

  1. 1

    The briefing

    Premise and conclusion · Validity and soundness · A priori and a posteriori · The Socratic method

  2. 2

    Introduction to Philosophy

    The Origins and Evolution of Western Philosophy · Major Eastern Philosophical Traditions

  3. 3

    Branches of Philosophy

    Definition and Scope · Key Concepts · Major Philosophers · Definition and Scope

  4. 4

    Major Philosophical Movements and Schools

    Platonism and Aristotelianism · Rationalism and Empiricism · Existentialism and Phenomenology · Analytic and Continental Philosophy

  5. 5

    Critical Thinking and Logic

    Principles of Logical Reasoning · Fallacies and Biases in Reasoning · The Role of Argumentation and Debate · Critical Thinking in Everyday Life

  6. 6

    Ethics and Moral Philosophy

    Contemporary Ethical Dilemmas and Debates · Moral Psychology and Evolution of Morality

  7. 7

    Philosophy of Mind and Consciousness

    Mind-Body Problem and Dualism · Theories of Consciousness · Artificial Intelligence and Philosophy of Mind · Free Will and Determinism

  8. 8

    Political Philosophy and Social Theory

    Theories of State and Government · Social Contract Theory · Marxism, Capitalism, and Anarchism · Justice, Rights, and Democracy

  9. 9

    Epistemology and Philosophy of Science

    The Nature and Scope of Knowledge (Expanded) · Defining Knowledge · Sources of Knowledge · The Limits of Knowledge

  10. 10

    Aesthetics and Philosophy of Art

    Definition and Evaluation of Art (Expanded) · Historical Perspectives on Art · Contemporary Definitions · Evaluation and Criticism

  11. 11

    Modern and Contemporary Philosophical Issues

    The Challenge of Postmodernism · Philosophy in the Age of Globalization · Ethical Challenges in a Technological World · Intersections of Philosophy with Other Disciplines

  12. 12

    Practical Applications of Philosophy

    Philosophy in Everyday Decision Making · Philosophy in Professional Life · Teaching Philosophy and Critical Thinking Skills · Philosophy as a Way of Life

  13. 13

    Conclusion and Further Readings

    Summarization of Key Philosophical Insights · Recommendations for Further Study · The Continuing Relevance of Philosophy

From the text

The Western tradition runs from the Greeks through medieval theology to the modern split between rationalists, who trusted reason, and empiricists, who trusted the senses. Kant tried to join them. Parallel traditions in India and China asked the same questions with different starting points. The practical payoff is critical thinking: separating a claim from the reasons offered for it, and noticing when the reasons do not reach.

Keep reading in the Atlas

Figures

People to know.

Socratesc. 470-399 BC

Taught by questioning, wrote nothing

Aristotle384-322 BC

Gave logic its first formal rules

Immanuel Kant1724-1804

Asked what the mind adds to what it sees

Hypatiac. 355-415

Philosopher and mathematician of Alexandria

Confucius551-479 BC

Built an ethics around duty and conduct

Canon

Books to read.

  • The RepublicPlato
  • MeditationsMarcus Aurelius
  • The Problems of PhilosophyBertrand Russell
  • Thinking, Fast and SlowDaniel Kahneman
From the viva

A question from its final exam.

Which branch of philosophy studies knowledge and how we come to have it?

Who is in it

63 people, each one explained.

Twelve of them are below. In the Atlas every name, work and place in the text opens a short account of who or what it is.

  • Plato c. 429 BC to c. 349 BC
    4th-century BCE Greek philosopher
  • Aristotle c. 384 BC to c. 322 BC
    Greek philosopher
  • Kant 1724 to 1804
    German philosopher
  • Descartes 1596 to 1650
    French philosopher, mathematician, and scientist
  • John Rawls 1921 to 2002
    American philosopher, philosophy teacher
  • Marx 1818 to 1883
    German-born philosopher
  • David Hume 1711 to 1776
    Scottish philosopher, economist, and historian
  • Hegel 1770 to 1831
    German philosopher and theologian
  • Jacques Derrida 1930 to 2004
    French philosopher
  • Nietzsche 1844 to 1900
    German philosopher
  • Socrates c. 470 BC to c. 399 BC
    5th-century BCE Greek philosopher
  • Thomas Aquinas 1225 to 1274
    Italian Dominican friar, philosopher, Catholic priest, and Doctor of the Church

Descriptions and dates from Wikidata. Portraits from Wikimedia Commons, each linked to its author and license.

Also worth knowing

What a full picture of the field includes.

Every chapter was checked against a list of the names and terms a student of the subject should meet. These are the most important ones the book itself does not name.

Syllogism

An argument with two premises and a conclusion, such as: all humans are mortal, Socrates is human, so Socrates is mortal. Aristotle made it the first formal system of logic.

Avicenna980 to 1037

Persian philosopher and physician, known in Arabic as Ibn Sina. He joined Aristotle's thought to Islamic theology, and his "flying man" thought experiment argued that the self knows itself without the body.

Averroes1126 to 1198

Philosopher of Islamic Spain, known in Arabic as Ibn Rushd. His commentaries brought Aristotle back to Europe and defended reason as a path to truth beside religion.

Hannah Arendt1906 to 1975

Political thinker who studied totalitarianism and coined the phrase "the banality of evil" for the way ordinary people carry out terrible orders without thinking.

Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel1770 to 1831

German philosopher who saw history as ideas clashing and being absorbed into something larger. Marx and most later European philosophy answer him.

Thomas Aquinas1225 to 1274

Medieval theologian who combined Aristotle with Christian teaching and gave five famous arguments for the existence of God.

Zhuangzic. 369 BC to c. 288 BC

Daoist thinker famous for dreaming he was a butterfly, then asking whether he was a butterfly dreaming of being a man. He questioned how sure anyone can be.

Nagarjuna150 to 250

Indian Buddhist philosopher who argued that nothing has a fixed, independent nature. Everything exists only in relation to other things.

Read Philosophy and Critical Thinking.

Free. The film, the briefing and the first section open without an account.